Skip to content
Comrade Ammara

8. The tendency of the rate of profit to fall and its countertendencies

Marx formulates the TRPF as a tendency of capitalist accumulation:[6, 42]

Marx argues that, other things equal, accumulation tends to raise the organic composition of capital: more machinery, technology, and materials are set in motion per worker. Since only living labour produces new value, a rising \(c\) relative to \(v\) tends, over long periods, to press down the rate of profit, unless counter-tendencies (higher exploitation, cheapening of elements of constant capital, foreign trade, etc.) offset it.

“[T]he gradual growth of constant capital in relation to variable capital must necessarily lead to a gradual fall of the general rate of profit …”[6]

The mathematics is compact in Eq. (7.2): if \(\mathrm{OCC}\) rises while \(e\) is constant, then the rate of profit \(r\) must fall. But Marx immediately adds that this tendency is modified by counteracting influences.

8.1 Counteracting tendencies

Marx identifies several counteracting influences that can offset or slow the fall in the rate of profit:

  1. Raising the rate of surplus value through longer working hours, intensified labour, or a reduction in necessary labour time.

  2. Depressing wages below the value of labour-power.

  3. Cheapening the elements of constant capital, for example through productivity gains in the production of machinery, energy, and raw materials.

  4. Foreign trade, insofar as it cheapens productive inputs and the commodities required to reproduce labour-power, while also opening wider markets for accumulation.

Other processes can relieve pressure on profitability without being identical to these counteracting influences. These include the opening of new branches of production and commodification, the export of capital, and the devaluation or destruction of capital through bankruptcies, write-offs, and crises. Such mechanisms can offset, postpone, or reshape the tendency, but they do not abolish it. Capitalist cycles arise through their interaction with accumulation, competition, credit, overproduction, and periodic devaluation.

8.2 Empirical patterns

Measurement limits and the Okishio objection.

Two points prevent common misunderstandings.

First, empirical “profit rates” are constructed in different ways (before/after tax, historical cost versus current cost, with/without purely financial gains, different sectoral boundaries, and different treatments of depreciation and inventories). Marx’s argument concerns the profitability of productive capital in historically unfolding accumulation, so any empirical proxy has to be read with its construction in mind.[36, 42]1

Second, there is a well-known theoretical objection associated with the Okishio theorem: if capitalists adopt only cost-reducing technical changes and the real wage is held constant, the competitive equilibrium profit rate rises rather than falls.[43]2 Marxists respond by disputing the closure (especially the constant-real-wage assumption), by distinguishing equilibrium comparisons from historically unfolding accumulation with crises and devaluation, and by stressing that technical change is driven by class struggle and competitive coercion in ways that can raise capital intensity faster than exploitation rises.3 The TRPF is therefore not a mechanical prediction of monotone decline, but a claim about the direction of pressure created by rising capital intensity under capitalist conditions, mediated through countertendencies and crises.

Empirical work by Marxist economists suggests that, across many advanced capitalist economies, profitability tends to fall over long periods, interrupted by partial recoveries, and that major crises are often preceded by profit squeezes.[42, 36]

The details remain debated. The argument defended here is that accumulation and competition repeatedly push firms towards greater mechanisation and capital intensity, tending to raise the technical composition of capital and, where this is reflected in value terms, the ratio \(c/v\). This places recurrent downward pressure on profitability, though the result is mediated by the counteracting tendencies discussed above. Credit and financial speculation can sustain demand, extend accumulation, and postpone devaluation for a time, but they also enlarge the claims resting on future surplus value and can increase the scale of the subsequent adjustment.4


  1. In national accounts and firm accounts, what counts as “profit” can include or exclude interest, rents, taxes, capital gains, and various imputed items; the capital stock can be valued at historical or replacement cost; and depreciation can be treated in different ways. These choices shift levels and sometimes timing, but they do not remove the structural link Marx is emphasising between accumulation (rising capital intensity) and profitability pressures over time. ↩

  2. Okishio’s result is a theorem about a particular comparison of equilibria under specified assumptions (including a constant real wage and the adoption of only cost-reducing techniques). It therefore does not settle the historically concrete question of how profitability evolves under capitalist accumulation with wage struggles, credit cycles, uneven technical change, and periodic crises and devaluations. ↩

  3. Even when a new technique is locally cost-reducing, its generalisation can change prices, reorganise sectoral compositions, and intensify competitive pressures; wages, hours, and labour intensity are also objects of struggle. Accumulation therefore generates recurring downward pressures mediated by countertendencies and crisis mechanisms, including devaluation, the cheapening of inputs, destruction of capital, and the export of capital. ↩

  4. This is also why financial booms are often read, in Marxian terms, as attempts to sustain accumulation and realise surplus value when productive profitability is strained: credit can extend demand and postpone devaluation, but it also raises the stakes of the eventual adjustment. ↩