7. Rate of profit and organic composition of capital¶
Under the simplifying one-turnover convention used here, the rate of profit is the central ratio from the capitalist’s point of view. It expresses surplus value as a proportion of the total capital advanced:
From the definition of the exploitation rate in Eq. (5.2), \(e = s/v\), we have \(s = e v\), so we can rewrite the rate of profit as
where, for expository simplicity, \(\ensuremath{\mathrm{OCC}}=c/v\) is used as shorthand for the organic composition of capital. Strictly speaking, \(c/v\) is the value composition of capital; Marx calls it the organic composition insofar as changes in this value ratio reflect changes in the underlying technical composition of production.
7.1 Illustration: varying the organic composition¶
Suppose, for simplicity, that the exploitation rate is fixed at \(e= 100\%\), i.e. \(s= v\), and set \(v=100\) as a numéraire. We examine what happens to \(r\) as the ratio \(c/v\) rises.
| \(c/v\) | \(c\) | \(s\) | \(r = \dfrac{s}{c+v}\) |
|---|---|---|---|
| \(0.5\) | \(50\) | \(100\) | \(\approx 66.7\%\) |
| \(1.0\) | \(100\) | \(100\) | \(50.0\%\) |
| \(2.0\) | \(200\) | \(100\) | \(\approx 33.3\%\) |
| \(4.0\) | \(400\) | \(100\) | \(20.0\%\) |
| \(8.0\) | \(800\) | \(100\) | \(\approx 11.1\%\) |
Even with a constant rate of exploitation \(e=s/v=100\%\), the rate of profit \(r\) falls as constant capital rises relative to variable capital, that is, as the ratio \(c/v\) increases. Under the simplifying convention used here, this rising value composition is treated as an expression of a rising organic composition of capital. The resulting downward pressure on \(r\), other things equal, is the basic relation underlying Marx’s law of the tendency of the rate of profit to fall (TRPF).[42, 36]
7.2 Competition, average profit, and prices of production¶
So far we have treated \(s\) and \(r\) at the level of production: surplus value is produced where living labour is set to work, and the profit rate is \(r= s/(c+v)\) (Eq. (7.1)). But on the surface of capitalist society, capitals do not simply pocket the surplus they individually produce. They compete, they move, and they compare returns. This movement produces a tendency toward an average rate of profit.
Three related levels: values, prices of production, market prices.¶
It helps to be explicit about three levels of analysis that are often conflated in casual discussion:
-
Values express socially necessary labour time (in this pamphlet, expressed in money via the simplifying convention stated earlier). At this level, for industry \(i\),
\[ w_i = c_i + v_i + s_i. \] -
Prices of production are the regulating prices associated with competitive equalisation of profit rates. At this level,
\[ p_i = k_i(1+r), \qquad k_i = c_i + v_i. \] -
Market prices are the actual prices paid on the day. They deviate from regulating prices of production due to supply and demand fluctuations, credit conditions, state policy, and monopoly power; in competitive conditions they tend to oscillate around regulating prices, but in many real markets they can be persistently displaced.
When we do simple arithmetic in earlier sections (for example the smartphone example), we are effectively working at level (1)—as if market prices coincided with values—to keep the exploitation relation transparent. In this section we introduce level (2) to show that even without fraud, “overcharging,” or an individual capitalist “being greedy,” competition redistributes surplus value across capitals, generating systematic deviations between \(w_i\) and \(p_i\).
To formalise this, index industries (or branches of production) by \(i\). Let the capital advanced in industry \(i\) be \((c_i + v_i)\). Assume, for clarity, that the rate of exploitation is uniform across industries, so that in each industry
Then the value (in money terms) of the industry’s output (at this level of abstraction) can be written as
Here \(w_i\) is the value of output expressed in money terms under the simplifying convention stated earlier, not yet a regulating competitive price.
Define the cost price (capital advanced that must be replaced) as
The cost price \(k_i\) is the relevant base for competitive profit comparison: capitals compare returns on the total capital they advance, not only on the variable capital that purchases labour-power.
Total surplus value and total capital advanced are
Competition tends to equalise profit rates, so the average rate of profit is
This is the regulating (tendential) profit rate generated by the movement of capitals. It is not an ethical average but a competitive one: capitals flow away from below-average returns and into above-average returns, pressuring outcomes toward the social average.
Under this tendency, the regulating price is not the direct value \(w_i\) but the price of production, which yields the average profit on the capital advanced:
The profit received by industry \(i\) is therefore
Compare this with surplus value produced in that industry, \(s_i=ev_i\). The difference is
which expresses the redistribution of surplus value across industries through competition. In Marx’s terms: surplus value is produced in production by living labour, but it is distributed across capitals through competition, so that each capital tends to receive profit proportional to the total capital it advances, not proportional to the surplus it directly produces.
It is useful to make the dependence on the organic composition explicit. Let \(C=\sum_i c_i\) and \(V=\sum_i v_i\). With \(s=eV\) we have
Then, using \(\Omega = C/V\) as the average organic composition, one can show
So industries with above-average \(c_i/v_i\) tend to have \(p_i>w_i\) (they receive more profit than the surplus they themselves produce), while those with below-average \(c_i/v_i\) tend to have \(p_i<w_i\).
Limits to this example.¶
Under these simplifying assumptions,1 the logic is sharp: equalisation of profit rates implies systematic divergences between the value of output \(w_i\) and the regulating competitive price \(p_i\), even when each industry’s exploitation rate is assumed the same. This is why observed profit in a given sector cannot be read off as “the surplus produced here” without specifying the level of abstraction and the redistribution mechanisms.
A two-industry illustration (values vs. prices of production)¶
Example 7.1: Two industries and the redistribution of surplus value
Assume two industries, \(A\) and \(B\), with a common exploitation rate \(e= 100\%\), so \(s_i = v_i\). Let \(v_A=v_B=100\), and let \(A\) be lower-composition and \(B\) higher-composition:
Step 1: Surplus value produced and values.¶
Since \(e=100\%\), we have
So values (Eq. (7.3)) are:
Step 2: The average profit rate.¶
Totals are \(C=200\), \(V=200\), \(s=200\), so the average profit rate is
Step 3: Prices of production and profits received.¶
Prices of production (Eq. (7.6)) are:
Profits received are \(\pi_i = p_i - (c_i+v_i)=r(c_i+v_i)\), hence
Step 4: Who transfers surplus value, and who receives it?¶
Industry \(A\) sells below its value (\(225<250\)) and receives less profit than the surplus it produces:
Industry \(B\) sells above its value (\(375>350\)) and receives more profit than the surplus it produces:
| Industry | \(c\) | \(v\) | \(s\) (produced) | \(w=c+v+s\) | \(k=c+v\) | \(p=k(1+r)\) | \(\pi=rk\) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| \(A\) | 50 | 100 | 100 | 250 | 150 | 225 | 75 |
| \(B\) | 150 | 100 | 100 | 350 | 250 | 375 | 125 |
| Total | 200 | 200 | 200 | 600 | 400 | 600 | 200 |
Aggregate identities.¶
Under these simplifying assumptions,2
So prices of production redistribute surplus value; they do not create it. Market prices can fluctuate around \(p_i\) due to demand, supply, monopoly power, state policy, and world-market conditions, but the competitive tendency toward average profit is the key mediating mechanism through which labour-time asserts itself in the long run.[6, 36]
How labour-time regulates prices.¶
Saying that labour-time “asserts itself” does not mean that values are directly observable in prices at any moment, nor that capitalism settles into a frictionless equilibrium. It means that, through the movement of capitals and the coercive discipline of competition, production is reorganised over time so that techniques, branch allocations, and capacities are pressured toward the social average, with crises and devaluation as violent moments of rebalancing. This is why Marx treats prices of production as mediations: they are the forms through which the underlying value relations appear and operate in capitalist reality, not a separate sphere that floats free of production.
7.3 Modern intuition¶
Think of the evolution of car production. A hundred years ago, producing a car required many hours of relatively low-mechanisation labour. Today, large parts of the process are automated: robots weld, paint, and assemble; software optimises flows. The ratio \(c/v\) has risen massively.
At the level of an individual firm, this may boost profits for a while, because the firm gets ahead of the social average and sells at prices that embody more labour time than it actually expends. But as the new technology diffuses, the industry-wide \(\mathrm{SNLT}\) falls, values fall, and competitive pressures reassert themselves. At a given or even rising exploitation rate, the long-run tendency is for \(r\) to come under pressure.
-
We abstract from fixed capital turnover-time differences, depreciation schedules, joint production, rent and taxation, credit and interest, state subsidies, and open-economy complications (exchange rates, tariffs, and persistent monopoly power). These matter greatly for how value magnitudes map onto observed accounting categories, but they do not change the core point demonstrated here: surplus value is produced by living labour in production and then redistributed through competition and further shaped by credit and state power. ↩
-
This stylised example abstracts from fixed capital and turnover-time differences, depreciation schedules, joint production, rent, taxes, interest-bearing capital, state subsidies, and open-economy complications (exchange rates, tariffs, unequal exchange). These omissions affect how value magnitudes map onto observed accounting categories and how long-run centres of gravitation are formed, but they do not change the core point established here: surplus value is produced by living labour in production and then redistributed through competition, credit, and state power. ↩