Skip to content
Comrade Ammara

6. Constant and variable capital; circuits of capital

To move from exploitation at the point of production to the dynamics of the system as a whole, we need to distinguish types of capital.[5]

6.1 Constant and variable capital

  • Constant capital (\(c\)) is the value of the means of production: machinery, buildings, raw materials, intermediate goods. Its value is transferred to the product but does not itself create new value.

  • Variable capital (\(v\)) is the value advanced to buy labour-power (wages, broadly understood). It is called “variable” because it is the part of capital that can create more value than it costs.

If we consider one turnover of capital, the value of the total commodity product is:

\[ W = c+ v+ s. \tag{6.1} \]

The cost price for the capitalist is:

\[ k = c+ v, \tag{6.2} \]

while the surplus value \(s\) is the excess of value over cost. For the simplified examples below, assume one turnover and treat the constant capital advanced during the period as fully consumed or transferred to the output. Strictly speaking, the value of the commodity product contains only the constant capital used up during production, including the depreciation of fixed capital, while the denominator of the profit rate includes the total capital advanced. Once fixed capital, different depreciation schedules, and unequal turnover times are introduced, the same \(c\) cannot be used for both without further qualification.

Example 6.1: A documented producer-stage cost table for one football

We can now return to the Sialkot football case introduced in Example 5.2, but at a different level of analysis. There we compared the worker’s piece-rate wage with the downstream retail price. Here we use the source’s producer-stage cost table. These are accounting figures: they can illustrate the relation between non-wage costs, wage costs, total cost, markup, and profit, but they cannot be read directly as measurements of Marxian \(c\), \(v\), and \(s\).

Consider the production-cost breakdown for a size-5 two-layer promotional football reported in the online appendix to Atkin et al.’s study of Sialkot soccer-ball producers.1

The source reports the following approximate costs per ball:

Input PKR per ball Treatment in this example
rexine \(39.68\) \(c_{\text{proxy}}\)
cotton/poly cloth \(23.27\) \(c_{\text{proxy}}\)
latex \(38.71\) \(c_{\text{proxy}}\)
bladder \(42.02\) \(c_{\text{proxy}}\)
overhead \(10.84{}\) mixed / unspecified
labour for cutting \(1.49\) \(v_{\text{proxy}}\)
labour for stitching \(39.24{}\) \(v_{\text{proxy}}\)
other labour \(15.56\) \(v_{\text{proxy}}\)
total reported cost \(210.83{}\) \(k_{\text{acct}}\)

Treating the specified material inputs as a rough proxy for constant capital used up in production gives:

\[ c_{\text{proxy}} \approx 39.68+23.27+38.71+42.02 \approx \text{PKR }143.68{}. \]

Treating the reported labour-cost rows as a rough proxy for variable capital gives:

\[ v_{\text{proxy}} \approx 1.49+39.24{}+15.56 \approx \text{PKR }56.29{}. \]

The source also reports:

\[ o_{\text{overhead}} = \text{PKR }10.84{}. \]

The reconstructed accounting cost is therefore:

\[ k_{\text{acct}} = c_{\text{proxy}} + v_{\text{proxy}} + o_{\text{overhead}} \approx \text{PKR }210.81{}. \]

The source reports a total cost of approximately \(\text{PKR }210.83{}\); the small difference results from rounding in the individual rows.

The same study reports a mean producer-stage profit margin for size-5 promotional balls of roughly \(m=8.1{}\%\).2

Using the reported total cost and this markup, the estimated producer-stage selling price is:

\[ p_{\text{prod}} = k_{\text{acct}} \Bigl(1+\frac{m}{100}\Bigr) \approx \text{PKR }210.83{} \times 1.081 \approx \text{PKR }227.91{}. \]

The corresponding producer-stage accounting profit is:

\[ \pi_{\text{prod}} = p_{\text{prod}}-k_{\text{acct}} \approx \text{PKR }227.91{} - \text{PKR }210.83{} \approx \text{PKR }17.08{}. \]

The accounting profit-to-wage-cost ratio is therefore:

\[ \frac{\pi_{\text{prod}}}{v_{\text{proxy}}} \approx \frac{17.08}{56.29} \approx 0.303 \quad\Rightarrow\quad 30.3{}\%. \]

This \(30.3{}\%\) figure is not an empirical measurement of the Marxian rate of exploitation \(s/v\). Such an estimate would require a fuller reconstruction of value magnitudes, including the composition of overhead, the distinction between productive and circulation labour, depreciation, turnover times, input prices, and the redistribution of surplus value across capitals.

Nor does the calculation mean that the total profit associated with a branded football is only \(\text{PKR }17.08{}\). It shows a documented accounting relation at one producer stage: material costs, wage costs, overhead, total cost, and accounting profit. The prices and revenues that arise later in the supply chain are shaped by export contracts, logistics, branding, retail, finance, rent, monopoly power, and the wider redistribution of surplus value.

Why “selling above market price” cannot explain profit.

A common intuition is that profit comes from selling dear: buy for \(100\), sell for \(120\). But as a general explanation of profit for the whole capitalist class, this cannot work.

Example (1): pure price mark-up is redistribution, not creation. Suppose Merchant A buys a commodity for $100 and sells it to Merchant B for $120. A gains $20, but B has paid $20 more than the prevailing market price. Across the two merchants taken together, no new value is created by this exchange; $20 has simply been transferred from B to A. If everyone tried to “sell above market price” at the same time, the “market price” would just re-set upward. The question would return in the same form: where does the extra money come from in the aggregate?

Example (2): profit without any mark-up. Now consider a capitalist who advances \(c=80\) for inputs and depreciation, and \(v=20\) in wages. Living labour produces new value \(v+s= 40\), so the commodity product has value

\[ W = c+ v+ s= 80 + 20 + 20 = 120. \]

If the capitalist sells the output at its value $120 (no overcharging at all), the cost price is \(k=c+v=100\), so profit is

\[ W-k = 120-100=20, \]

which is exactly the surplus value \(s\).

Selling above (or below) value can redistribute surplus value between capitals (as shown in Section 7.2), especially under monopoly power. But the system-wide source of profit is surplus value extracted from labour-power. Profit appears here even though the commodity is sold at its value, because the source is the surplus value \(s\) created in production.

With this cleared up, we can return to the movement of capital itself: how money is advanced, turned into means of production and labour-power, and then returns expanded as \(M'\). This is what Marx captures in the basic circuits of circulation.

6.2 Circuits of capital

Marx contrasts two circuits:

\[ \begin{align} \ensuremath{C \text{--} M \text{--} C}&: C \rightarrow M \rightarrow C, \tag{6.3} \\ \ensuremath{M \text{--} C \text{--} M'}&: M \rightarrow C \rightarrow M'. \tag{6.4} \end{align} \]
  • In \(C \rightarrow M \rightarrow C\), a small producer sells a commodity \(C\) for money \(M\) in order to buy another commodity \(C\), for example a farmer selling grain to buy tools and food. The goal is use-value.

  • The same general form also describes the worker’s circuit, though the commodity sold at the beginning is labour-power rather than a finished product. More precisely, it can be written as

    \[ \mathrm{LP} \rightarrow M \rightarrow C. \]

    The worker sells labour-power, \(\mathrm{LP}\), for a money wage \(M\), then spends that wage on commodities \(C\) needed to live and return to work—food, housing, transport, childcare, medicine, and so on. The wage is not payment for all the value created during the working day; it is the money-form of the value of labour-power. Households, care, and unpaid work are therefore part of political economy itself, since they help reproduce the labour-power on which wage-labour depends.

  • Money is not a neutral mediator of trade in capitalist society. It is an everyday form of constraint: people generally gain access to housing, food, transport, care, and other conditions of life through wages or other monetary incomes. Nature does not demand payment for land, water, or energy. That demand arises from property relations and their enforcement, which allow the conditions of life to be monopolised and sold. Money is therefore more than a convenient means of exchange; it is the form in which private control over social wealth confronts the majority as a daily necessity.

  • In \(M \rightarrow C \rightarrow M'\), a capitalist advances money \(M\) to purchase means of production and labour-power, which are then brought together in production. The resulting commodities are sold for

    \[ M' = M + \Delta M. \]

    The aim of the circuit is the increment \(\Delta M\), that is, surplus value realised in money-form.

    Written more fully, the circuit of money-capital through production is:

    \[ M \rightarrow C\{\mathrm{MP},\mathrm{LP}\} \dots P \dots C' \rightarrow M', \]

    where \(\mathrm{MP}\) denotes means of production, \(\mathrm{LP}\) labour-power, and \(P\) the production process. The prime in \(C'\) indicates that the commodity product contains more value than the capital initially advanced, because surplus value has been produced in the labour process. That surplus is realised in money-form only when \(C'\) is sold for \(M'\).

Capital is therefore best understood not as a thing (a machine) but as a social relation and a circuit: value in motion that valorises itself through the exploitation of labour, and that necessarily appears and is realised in monetary form as \(M \rightarrow M'\).


  1. Atkin et al. report the table as Appendix Table A.1, “Production Costs”. The figures are mean input costs in rupees per ball from their baseline survey. See[53]. The NBER working-paper version is[54]. ↩

  2. The paper reports profit percentages for size-5 promotional balls in its baseline summary statistics. It also explains that unit cost is recovered by dividing reported price by \(1+\) the reported profit margin, so the margin is treated here as a markup on cost. ↩