Skip to content
Comrade Ammara

5. Labour-power, wages, surplus labour, and surplus value

A central conceptual breakthrough in Capital is the distinction between labour and labour-power.[5]

  • Labour-power is the worker’s capacity to work, treated as a commodity. Its value is the socially necessary labour time required to reproduce labour-power under historically and socially specific conditions: food, housing, clothing, healthcare, transport, relevant education and training, social support, and the reproduction of the working class across generations.

  • Labour is the actual activity performed during the working day.

The capitalist buys labour-power for a wage, but receives labour itself. The secret of profit lies in the difference between the value produced by labour and the value of labour-power.

5.1 What the worker sells: labour-power, not labour

In everyday speech we say workers “sell their labour.” Marx insists this is misleading. What workers sell is labour-power: the capacity to work for a given time under the employer’s control.

That distinction is not a semantic trick; it is the logical key. If workers sold labour itself as a commodity, then its price (the wage) would have to equal the value labour produces. Profit would be impossible except by cheating.

Under capitalism, the wage can be an equivalent exchange even while exploitation occurs, because the exchange is:

\[ \text{wage} \longleftrightarrow \text{labour-power for } T \text{ hours}, \]

and the use-value of labour-power is precisely that it can create new value during those \(T\) hours. The capitalist pays for the reproduction cost of that capacity (the value of labour-power), but purchases control over its use in production for the whole working day.

So the contract is for labour-power, not labour itself. This distinction is the hinge of the pamphlet: it lets us explain exploitation without assuming cheating, and it lets us define \(v\) and \(s\) in a way that maps directly onto the working day.

In Marx’s shorthand, \(v\) (variable capital) is the value advanced as wages to buy labour-power. When labour-power is put to work for the full \(T\) hours, it creates new value greater than \(v\). The portion of new value that merely replaces the wage is necessary labour (corresponding to \(v\)), while the remaining portion is surplus value \(s\), the money-form of unpaid surplus labour time.

A terminology map: surplus, surplus labour, surplus value, profit, exploitation

Because these terms are often mixed up, fix the levels of analysis:

  • Surplus (general): output beyond what is immediately required to reproduce labour and social life at a given level (extra grain, stored food, extra cloth, extra labour-time, etc.). Surplus can exist in many kinds of society; the political question is who controls it and on what basis (see Section 2.4).

  • Surplus labour (\(Ts\)): in capitalism, the part of the working day performed beyond the labour required to reproduce the worker (beyond necessary labour time \(Tn\)). This is a time category: it refers to unpaid labour-time.

  • Surplus value (\(s\)): the specifically capitalist form of surplus: the value (and therefore the money expression) created by surplus labour. It is produced in the labour process, because only living labour creates new value; but it must be realised through sale to appear in money-form (see Section 6.2).

  • Profit (\(\pi\)): the money-form of realised surplus value as it appears to the capitalist. In the simplest abstraction where commodities sell at their values, profit equals surplus value. But under competition and price formation, individual capitals can realise profits that differ from the surplus value they produce (see Section 7.2 and the discussion of \(\pi_i - s_i\)).

  • Exploitation (\(e\)): the social relation in which the producing class performs surplus labour and a ruling/owning class appropriates it. Under capitalism, exploitation is mediated through the wage: workers receive the value of labour-power as wages, but produce more value than they receive. The standard measure is the rate of exploitation \(e = s/v\), which we derive below.

Two common confusions to avoid. (1) Profit is not explained by a general “mark-up”: if one seller sells above value, another buys above value, so this redistributes surplus rather than creating it. (2) A firm’s realised profit is not a direct thermometer of how much exploitation it administers at the point of production, because surplus value is redistributed through competition, monopoly, and price formation.

We can now state this in the simplest temporal form: split the working day into the portion that reproduces the wage and the portion that produces surplus.

5.2 Necessary and surplus labour time

Assume the worker is paid the full value of labour-power, \(v\) (no cheating). In production, living labour adds new value; call the new value created in the day \((v+s)\). Since the capitalist owns the product, the worker receives \(v\) while the remainder \(s\) is appropriated as surplus-value. The puzzle is resolved: equal exchange in the wage contract is compatible with exploitation because the use-value of labour-power is value-creating labour.

Let the working day be \(T\) hours. Suppose the value of the worker’s labour-power corresponds to \(\ensuremath{T_{\mathrm{N}}}\) hours of labour—the necessary labour time. The remaining

\[ \ensuremath{T_{\mathrm{S}}}= T - \ensuremath{T_{\mathrm{N}}}, \tag{5.1} \]

is surplus labour time, during which the worker produces value for the capitalist without equivalent wages.

The new value created in the day is proportional to \(T\), but the worker is only paid for \(\ensuremath{T_{\mathrm{N}}}\). The surplus value is proportional to \(\ensuremath{T_{\mathrm{S}}}\):

\[ v \propto \ensuremath{T_{\mathrm{N}}}, \qquad s \propto \ensuremath{T_{\mathrm{S}}}. \]

We can therefore capture the rate of surplus value, or rate of exploitation, as

\[ e = \frac{s}{v} = \frac{\ensuremath{T_{\mathrm{S}}}}{\ensuremath{T_{\mathrm{N}}}}, \tag{5.2} \]

because the proportionality factors cancel when we take the ratio.

Here, \(v\) is the value of variable capital—the wages advanced—and \(s\) is the surplus value extracted.

5.3 Why surplus necessarily appears once labour-power is commodified

Now we can state the logic in one chain.

Let the money-value created per hour of socially necessary labour be \(\MELT\) (money/hour). If the working day lasts \(T\) hours, then the new value created in the day is:

\[ \text{new value} = \MELT \, T. \]

If the value of labour-power corresponds to \(\ensuremath{T_{\mathrm{N}}}\) hours of socially necessary labour, then the wage (variable capital) corresponds to:

\[ v = \MELT \, \ensuremath{T_{\mathrm{N}}}. \]

But the capitalist has purchased control over labour-power for the whole day \(T\), so the surplus value is the difference:

\[ \begin{aligned} s &= \MELT \, T \;-\; \MELT \, \ensuremath{T_{\mathrm{N}}}\\ &= \MELT \, (T - \ensuremath{T_{\mathrm{N}}}) \\ &= \MELT \, \ensuremath{T_{\mathrm{S}}}. \end{aligned} \]

So \(s\) is the quantitative expression of surplus labour time mediated through money.

This is why Marx insists on the labour / labour-power distinction: without it, you cannot explain profit as a normal outcome of equivalent exchange.

5.4 Absolute and relative surplus value: the two main ways capital raises exploitation

Section 5.3 established the baseline relation:

\[ s = \mu\,T_S=\mu\,(T-T_N), \qquad v=\mu\,T_N, \qquad e=\frac{s}{v}=\frac{T_S}{T_N}=\frac{T-T_N}{T_N}. \]

Once labour-power is commodified, the question for capital is not whether surplus value can be produced, but how to raise it. There are two structurally distinct levers.

Absolute surplus value: extend the working day, or intensify labour

Absolute surplus value increases, in the strict sense, when surplus labour time rises because the working day is lengthened while necessary labour time remains unchanged. In the simplest case, hold \(\ensuremath{T_{\mathrm{N}}}\) fixed and raise \(T\):

\[ \Delta \ensuremath{T_{\mathrm{N}}}= 0, \qquad \Delta T > 0 \;\Rightarrow\; \Delta \ensuremath{T_{\mathrm{S}}}= \Delta T \;\Rightarrow\; \Delta s = \mu\,\Delta T. \]

In concrete terms, longer shifts and forced overtime extend the period during which surplus labour is performed. Capital can also raise surplus value by intensifying labour through speed-up, tighter supervision, compressed breaks, higher output norms, and piece-rates. Intensification is not identical to prolonging the working day, because the clock-length of the day may remain the same. But it can have a similar practical effect: a given clock-hour contains a greater expenditure of labour than the prevailing normal intensity. This should not be described as a firm-level rise in the MELT. It is a change in labour intensity, and in the amount of labour socially validated within a given hour, not a change in the monetary expression of labour time itself.

Minimal numeric example.

If \(T=10\) hours and \(T_N=5\), then \(T_S=5\) and \(e=5/5=100\%\). If the day is extended to \(T=12\) with \(T_N\) still \(5\), then \(T_S=7\) and \(e=7/5=140\%\). Nothing “mystical” happened: the worker now performs more surplus labour time.

Relative surplus value: shrink necessary labour time

Relative surplus value increases when surplus labour time rises because necessary labour time falls, with the working day held constant (or not rising by as much). Formally, hold \(T\) fixed and reduce \(T_N\):

\[ \Delta T = 0, \qquad \Delta T_N < 0 \;\Rightarrow\; \Delta T_S = -\Delta T_N \;\Rightarrow\; \Delta s = \mu\,(-\Delta T_N). \]

But how does \(T_N\) fall? Because \(T_N\) represents the socially necessary labour-time required to reproduce labour-power: the labour-time embodied in the bundle of wage-goods and services workers must consume to show up again tomorrow, next week, next generation. When productivity rises in the sectors producing those wage-goods (food, clothing, transport, housing inputs, etc.), the value of that bundle can fall. Then the value of labour-power falls, and the portion of the working day needed to reproduce it (\(T_N\)) shrinks. Even if the working day stays the same, surplus labour expands.

Minimal numeric example.

If \(T=10\) and \(T_N=5\), then \(T_S=5\) and \(e=100\%\). If productivity changes (in wage-goods) reduce \(T_N\) to \(4\) while \(T\) remains \(10\), then \(T_S=6\) and \(e=6/4=150\%\).

Relative surplus value and wages below the value of labour-power.

Relative surplus value is about reducing the value of labour-power (reducing \(T_N\)). That is not identical to depressing wages below the value of labour-power. The latter is an additional mechanism (common in informalisation, migrant labour regimes, and reproduction crises) where the worker is paid less than what is socially required for reproduction. Analytically, keep these distinct: one changes the value of labour-power; the other violates it.

“Extra” surplus value and the competitive drive to revolutionise production

An individual firm can momentarily gain extra surplus value by introducing a technique that cuts the labour-time per unit below the social average. While the market still prices near the old social value, the innovating firm sells at that going price but produces at a lower individual value, pocketing an extra margin. Competition then forces generalisation: as the new technique spreads, the social average falls, commodity values fall, and what began as “extra” surplus value becomes a system-wide route to relative surplus value.

Why this matters for the rest of the pamphlet.

Absolute and relative surplus value are the basic grammar of class struggle under capitalism. They also connect directly to later sections: (1) countertendencies to falling profitability (raising \(e\) by extending/intensifying labour or cutting the value of labour-power), and (2) the chronic pressure to hold wages down relative to productivity, which shapes crisis dynamics.

5.5 Is this “theft”? Contract, coercion, and property relations

It is tempting to describe surplus value as “wage theft.” Sometimes employers do literally steal wages (illegal non-payment, underpayment, forced overtime without pay, intimidation that prevents workers from claiming contracted pay). But Marx’s concept of exploitation is deeper than that.

Difference between illegal wage theft and structural capitalist exploitation.

Illegal wage theft is widespread: non-payment, underpayment, forced overtime without pay, and intimidation that prevents workers from claiming their contracted wages. Marx’s account of exploitation does not depend on these violations. Even if every capitalist paid exactly what the law and employment contract stipulated, exploitation would still occur so long as labour-power remained a commodity and capital retained ownership of the means of production and, therefore, of the product. The core problem is not merely a defective or unlawfully administered contract, but the property relation that compels workers to enter the wage contract in the first place and enables capital to appropriate the surplus value they produce.

In the normal case, exploitation does not require the capitalist to cheat the worker at the point of exchange. The wage contract can be formally voluntary and “fair” in the sense that the worker is paid the value of labour-power. Exploitation remains compatible with equivalent exchange because capital purchases control over labour-power for the whole working day rather than the value the worker creates during that day.

The coercion is structural: workers are separated from the means of production and must sell labour-power to live. Because capital owns the workplace, machines, land, and inputs, it also owns the product and the surplus. That is why exploitation is a property relation reproduced daily through “free” contracts.1

So the Marxian claim is:

  • exploitation is not primarily a matter of bad individuals stealing;

  • it is a normal outcome of capitalist production once labour-power is a commodity;

  • therefore it cannot be abolished by appeals to fairness or by contract reform alone, while the wage relation and private ownership of the main means of production remain.2

This is exactly why the horizon of struggle is not only better terms inside the wage relation, but ultimately the abolition of the wage relation itself.3

5.6 Example: a coffee-shop worker

Consider a barista in a large coffee chain in a global North city. The numbers below are illustrative, not taken from an actual shop’s accounts. To keep the example simple, assume that the day’s output sells at its value, that all used-up inputs and wages for the productive labour involved are included, and that rent, interest, taxes, franchise fees, and similar claims are left out. On these assumptions, whatever remains after replacing constant and variable capital is treated as surplus value.

Example 5.1: A coffee-shop worker

Suppose:

  • The shop sells drinks and snacks worth $800 during an 8-hour shift.

  • Of this, $300 covers the value of used-up constant capital (beans, milk, cups, energy, machine depreciation) — this is \(c\).

  • The barista’s wage bill for the shift is $100 — this is \(v\).

We want to find:

  • the new value created by living labour during the shift (\(v+ s\)),

  • the surplus value \(s\),

  • the rate of exploitation \(e\), and

  • how many hours of the 8-hour day are necessary labour time and how many are surplus labour time.

Step 1: Separate the value created by labour from the value of used-up machinery and inputs

The total value of the day’s output is $800. Of this, $300 is just the value of used-up constant capital \(c\) being transferred to the finished products. The remainder must therefore be new value created by living labour:

\[ \begin{aligned} \text{Total value of output} &= \$800,\\ \text{Value of used-up constant capital } (c) &= \$300,\\[0.5em] \Rightarrow\quad \text{New value created by labour } (v+ s) &= \text{Total value} - \text{Constant capital}\\ &= \$800 - \$300\\ &= \$500. \end{aligned} \]

So the labour of the barista has added $500 of new value during the shift:

\[ v+ s= \$500. \]

Step 2: Split this new value into wages and surplus-value

Out of this $500 of new value, the capitalist pays the barista $100 as wages. This $100 is the value of variable capital \(v\):

\[ v= \$100. \]

The rest of the new value is surplus-value \(s\):

\[ \begin{aligned} s &= (v+ s) - v\\ &= \$500 - \$100\\ &= \$400. \end{aligned} \]

So

\[ s= \$400. \]

Step 3: Compute the rate of exploitation

The rate of exploitation (or rate of surplus-value) is defined as the ratio of surplus-value to variable capital:

\[ e= \frac{s}{v}. \]

Plugging in our numbers:

\[ \begin{aligned} e &= \frac{s}{v}\\[0.3em] &= \frac{\$400}{\$100}\\[0.3em] &= 4. \end{aligned} \]

As a percentage:

\[ e= 4 \times 100\% = 400\%. \]

This means that, measured in value terms, the barista produces four times as much surplus for the owner as they receive back in wages.

Step 4: Translate the value relations into hours of the working day

The barista works an 8-hour shift. We know that, in value terms,

\[ v: s= 100 : 400 = 1 : 4. \]

So, of the new value ($500) created in the day, one-fifth belongs to necessary labour (reproducing the wage) and four-fifths is surplus labour.

Necessary labour time is therefore one-fifth of the working day:

\[ \begin{aligned} \text{Necessary labour time} &= \frac{v}{v+ s} \times 8\ \text{hours}\\[0.3em] &= \frac{100}{500} \times 8\\[0.3em] &= 0.2 \times 8\\[0.3em] &= 1.6\ \text{hours}. \end{aligned} \]

The remaining part of the working day is surplus labour time:

\[ \begin{aligned} \text{Surplus labour time} &= 8\ \text{hours} - 1.6\ \text{hours}\\[0.3em] &= 6.4\ \text{hours}. \end{aligned} \]

So in this simple coffee-shop example:

  • In the first \(1.6\) hours of the shift, the barista produces value equivalent to their own wage (necessary labour time).

  • In the remaining \(6.4\) hours, they produce surplus-value for the owner (surplus labour time).

  • Over the whole day, the rate of exploitation is \(e= 400\%\): for every $1 paid in wages, $4 of surplus-value is extracted.

This does not mean that the branch manager personally pockets $400. In this simplified example, the $400 represents surplus value before its later division among different claimants. Parts of it may appear as company profit, interest, rent, or franchise fees. Taxes are more complicated, since they may be paid out of profits, wages, rents, or other incomes. Nor should the calculation be read as something that could be taken directly from a shop’s accounts: if we used actual sales revenue and recorded costs, the remainder would be an accounting profit, which need not equal the surplus value produced in that shop.

5.7 Forms of wages: time-wages and piece-wages

Marx treats wages not only as a magnitude (\(v\)) but also as a form that can conceal exploitation.[5] Two classic forms are time-wages and piece-wages.

Time-wages

Under time-wages, the worker is paid per unit of time (hour/day/week/month). Let the money wage per hour be \(w_h\) and the paid hours in the period be \(T\). Then the money wage bill is

\[ W_w = w_h \, T. \]

Time-wages make it appear as if the worker is paid for all labour performed in those hours. But in Marxian terms, the wage is the price of labour-power, not the price of labour. What is purchased is the worker’s capacity to labour for \(T\) hours under capital’s control. The wage corresponds (in value terms) to \(v\), the value of labour-power, i.e. the socially necessary labour time required to reproduce the worker.

To connect money-wages to labour-time, introduce the monetary expression of labour time (MELT), \(\MELT\) (money per hour of socially necessary labour time). Then the value of labour-power corresponds to a quantity of necessary labour time \(\ensuremath{T_{\mathrm{N}}}\), and (schematically)

\[ v = \MELT \, \ensuremath{T_{\mathrm{N}}}, \qquad W_w \approx v. \]

The approximation sign here flags that money-wages and market prices do not, in general, equal values. Section 7.2 explains how competition and the tendency toward an average rate of profit generate prices of production that systematically diverge from values; market power, state policy, and world-market (exchange-rate and terms-of-trade) conditions can produce further, conjunctural deviations. Even if \(W_w\) equals the value of labour-power, exploitation still occurs because labour-power creates value over a working day longer than \(\ensuremath{T_{\mathrm{N}}}\).

Piece-wages

Under piece-wages, the worker is paid per unit output. Let output per hour be \(q\) units/hour and the piece rate be \(w_p\) money/unit. Then hourly pay is:

\[ w_h = w_p \, q \qquad\Rightarrow\qquad w_p = \frac{w_h}{q}. \]

For Marx, piece-wages are not a different substance of payment; they are time-wages in disguise. The piece-rate is derived from an assumed normal output per unit time (a socially enforced “standard” pace of work), and the worker is then pushed to meet or exceed that norm. Piece-wages therefore do not abolish time-wages; they are typically a modified time-wage in which the wage is tied more directly to labour intensity and output. In practice, this form often sharpens managerial control: it individualises pay, intensifies labour, and can shift risks of stoppages, defects, and speed-up onto workers, while leaving the basic relation unchanged—labour-power is still bought for a period, and surplus labour can still be extracted within (or by extending) the working day.

Why this matters

Piece-wages tend to:

  • intensify labour (workers self-discipline to increase \(q\));

  • shift monitoring costs from management to workers (“the numbers” police you);

  • increase competition among workers and weaken collective pacing and breaks.

But the underlying relation remains: the worker produces new value during the whole working day, while the wage corresponds to the value of labour-power. Wage-forms alter how exploitation is experienced, enforced, and fought over; they do not abolish the exploitation relation itself.

5.8 Example: Sialkot football stitching

Source years and comparability.

The Sialkot football examples below combine figures from different sources and years: piece-rate and time-per-ball benchmarks from 2022 reporting, producer-cost figures from a baseline survey in Atkin et al.’s Sialkot study, and retail/export benchmarks converted into PKR using a stated exchange-rate convention. It is not a single firm-year account, but rather calculated to make the class relation—wage, labour-time, producer-stage cost, surplus, and downstream price-forms—understandable for the reader.

Example 5.2: Sialkot football stitching: piece-wage, implied time-wage, and the retail-price gap

A piece-wage can be rewritten as a time-wage once we specify the time required to produce one unit.

Using widely reported benchmark figures for Sialkot-style hand-stitching, let the piece rate be

\[ w_{\text{piece}}=\text{PKR }160{}/\text{ball}, \]

and let the labour-time per ball be

\[ t_{\text{ball}}\approx 3\ \text{hours/ball}. \]

These figures are drawn from reporting on Sialkot football stitching in 2022 and are used here as an illustrative benchmark, not as a complete firm-level accounts sheet for a single year.4

Then the implied hourly wage is:

\[ w_{\text{hour}} = \frac{w_{\text{piece}}}{t_{\text{ball}}} \approx \frac{\text{PKR }160{}}{3\ \text{hours}} \approx \text{PKR }53.33{}/\text{hour}. \]

If the worker stitches roughly \(q=3\) balls per day, then:

\[ w_{\text{day}} = w_{\text{piece}}\times q = \text{PKR }160{} \times 3 = \text{PKR }480, \]

and

\[ T_{\text{day}} = t_{\text{ball}}\times q = 3 \times 3 = 9\ \text{hours}. \]

If this pace is sustained for roughly \(20\) paid workdays in a month, then monthly wage income is:

\[ w_{\text{month}} \approx \text{PKR }480 \times 20 = \text{PKR }9{,}600{}. \]

Against the same report’s quoted 2022 living-wage benchmark of about \(\text{PKR }20{,}000{}\) per month, this is:

\[ \frac{w_{\text{month}}}{L_{\text{month}}} \approx \frac{9{,}600}{20{,}000} = 0.48 \quad\Rightarrow\quad 48\%. \]

So even before we compare the wage to export or retail prices, the wage relation already appears as a social-reproduction problem: the missing income has to be made up through longer hours, debt, rationing, unpaid household labour, or some combination of these.

Now compare this wage with a downstream retail benchmark. Suppose a branded match ball retails at

\[ P_{\text{retail}}=\text{USD }165. \]

5 Using this fixed conversion benchmark:

\[ P_{\text{retail}} \approx 165\times \text{PKR }279.897{} \approx \text{PKR }46{,}183{}. \]

The number of wage-hours required to earn the retail price of one ball is:

\[ H = \frac{P_{\text{retail}}}{w_{\text{hour}}} \approx \frac{\text{PKR }46{,}183{}}{\text{PKR }53.33{}/\text{hour}} \approx 866{}\ \text{hours}. \]

Converted into footballs stitched and 9-hour workdays:

\[ \text{balls required} \approx \frac{H}{t_{\text{ball}}} \approx \frac{866}{3} \approx 289{}\ \text{balls}, \]
\[ \text{workdays required} \approx \frac{H}{T_{\text{day}}} \approx \frac{866}{9} \approx 96.2{}\ \text{workdays}. \]

So, under these benchmark assumptions, the worker would have to stitch roughly \(289{}\) footballs—nearly \(96\) nine-hour workdays—to earn enough wages to buy one branded match ball at the retail benchmark.

This calculation does not mean that the local employer pockets the full retail price. It shows something more specific: the same commodity confronts the stitcher as an alien object with a money-price set elsewhere in the chain. The wage-form is small relative to the price-forms the object later takes on in circulation, through export contracting, branding, logistics, retail markups, finance, and rent.

We return to the same industry in Example 6.1, after introducing constant capital, variable capital, cost price, and producer-stage surplus.

Piece-rates and technological change.

The Sialkot case also shows why technology is never just about “efficiency”. Atkin et al.’s study of Sialkot football producers examined a new cutting die that reduced waste of rexine, the main material input. From the owner’s standpoint, this looked like a straightforward cost-saving innovation. But the relevant workers were commonly paid by piece-rate. If the new technique slowed them down while they learned it, and if the piece-rate was not adjusted, then part of the cost of adoption was shifted onto workers as a lower effective hourly wage.[53]

A productive force does not enter society abstractly or in isolation, but through a labour process already organised by property, wages, supervision, and competition. Under capitalist control, even a technique that could reduce material waste can become a conflict over who bears the transition cost and who captures the gain. That same logic returns later in automation and AI: the question is not only what the tool can do, but who owns it, who controls its introduction, how it changes the pace of work, and whether the saving becomes free time for workers or surplus for capital.

5.9 Example: smartphone assembly

Simplifying convention: values and observed prices.

For simplicity in these numerical examples, treat observed money prices and costs as proportional to underlying values. In reality, prices can systematically deviate from values through competition and the redistribution of surplus value via prices of production; see Section 7.2. Market power, state policy, and world-market conditions can generate further deviations around these regulating prices.6

Return to the smartphone example. Suppose a batch of phones sells for $1.4 million. The costs are:

  • \(c= \$1{,}000{,}000\) in components, depreciation, logistics.7

  • \(v= \$200{,}000\) in direct wages at the assembly plant.

If the phones sell for $1.4 million, the surplus value realised on this batch is

\[ s= \$1{,}400{,}000 - (\$1{,}000{,}000 + \$200{,}000) = \$200{,}000. \tag{5.3} \]

Under the above convention, this residual is interpreted as surplus value realised on the batch. If one instead substitutes observed supplier prices and observed market prices, the same residual is best described as the firm’s realised profit on the transaction, which can diverge from surplus value produced in the assembly segment because value is redistributed through the global chain (and through competition, finance, and monopoly power).

The exploitation rate for the assembly labour (in this simplified example) is

\[ e= \frac{s}{v} = \frac{\$200{,}000}{\$200{,}000} = 1 \quad\Rightarrow\quad e= 100\%. \tag{5.4} \]

This is a toy measure that treats the wage bill \(v\) as the variable capital advanced by the assembly employer and \(s\) as the associated surplus realised under the simplifying assumptions. In reality, surplus value is generated across the whole production chain (raw materials, components, assembly, logistics, etc.), then redistributed across capitals through prices of production and further shaped by monopoly rents, IP regimes, and state power.

Two cautions matter for Marxian precision.

First, this arithmetic treats money magnitudes as proportional to values for clarity. In reality, competition, productivity differentials, and market power generate systematic value–price divergences (see Section 7.2); we flag this here but abstract from those divergences in the worked numbers.8

Second, surplus value is produced where productive labour is set to work in production processes that create commodities (or commodity-services) for sale.9 Much of what happens “downstream” (advertising, branding, some retail functions, finance) is better analysed as the realisation and redistribution of surplus value rather than its direct production. The brand and its shareholders can nonetheless capture surplus generated across the global chain through control of intellectual property, market access, finance, logistics, and pricing power (including transfer pricing and monopoly rents).[41, 59]


  1. This is the specific sense in which Marx calls the worker “free”: free to sell labour-power to any capitalist, but also free of property in the means of production. The “choice” is therefore constrained by the material need to reproduce life under conditions of dispossession. ↩

  2. Reforms matter for survival and bargaining power, and workers fight for them for good reason. They do not, by themselves, eliminate the production and appropriation of surplus so long as capital controls production and the product. ↩

  3. In plain terms: ending exploitation requires breaking the link between survival and selling labour-power, and socialising the major means of production so that the surplus produced by collective labour is democratically planned and used rather than privately appropriated. ↩

  4. Bloomberg Businessweek reported a piece-rate benchmark of roughly PKR \(160{}\) per ball, about three hours per ball, roughly three balls per day, and an illustrative monthly wage figure of roughly PKR \(9{,}600{}\); it also quotes a researcher-estimate living-wage benchmark of roughly PKR \(20{,}000{}\) per month. See[55]. ↩

  5. For the retail-price benchmark, see[57]. For the conversion below, we use the NBP Treasury rate sheet for 20 January 2026 as a fixed benchmark: \(1\,\text{USD}\approx\text{PKR }279.897{}\); see[68]. This is used only to make the comparison in PKR and should not be read as a retail foreign-exchange quotation. ↩

  6. In what follows, this “proportional to values” convention should be read as: we treat the money figures as value magnitudes expressed in money (as if a roughly constant conversion from socially necessary labour time to money were operating), and we treat the consumed inputs as if they enter at their values. This isolates the logic of exploitation and accumulation. When one instead plugs in observed supplier prices, the same subtraction yields an accounting residual (realised profit for this firm/segment) that can mix surplus value produced here with surplus value redistributed through mark-ups, transfer pricing, monopoly rents, and credit conditions. ↩

  7. Here \(c\) is being treated as the value transferred by used-up inputs (and depreciation of fixed capital) into the output—i.e. as if these inputs were purchased at their values under the simplifying convention stated above. If instead we used observed input prices (supplier prices, contract prices, internal transfer prices), that figure could already include redistributed surplus value, so the residual computed below would not be a clean measure of surplus value produced by assembly labour alone. ↩

  8. This matters especially for global value chains: the retail price of a branded device can sit far above the labour-time value embodied in the device because the price contains monopoly rents (IP, brand, platform control) and because surplus value is redistributed through supplier mark-ups, logistics contracts, and financial claims. The worked numbers should therefore be read as clarifying the logic of exploitation, not as a literal decomposition of the final retail price. ↩

  9. Here “unproductive” refers to a Marxian distinction between production and circulation. It does not mean useless or socially unimportant. It refers to labour that does not directly produce new value and surplus value for capital, even when that labour is necessary for circulation, control, coordination, or the realisation and distribution of surplus. ↩