Skip to content
Comrade Ammara

3. Commodities, value, use-value, and exchange-value

Marx opens Capital with the line that the wealth of societies where the capitalist mode of production rules appears as an “immense collection of commodities”.[5] That opening is not literary decoration. It is a methodological claim: capitalism first confronts us as a world of things with prices, and behind those things is a specific social relation. To understand capitalism, Marx begins with its simplest and most everyday cell-form: the commodity.

3.1 What is a commodity?

A commodity is a useful product or service produced for exchange. It therefore has a use-value, and it has a value that appears through exchange-value and, under developed monetary exchange, through price.

Not every useful thing is a commodity. A meal cooked at home for yourself or your friends is useful, but it is not produced for sale, and it does not have to realise itself as money in order to be eaten. The same meal produced in a commercial kitchen and sold through a delivery platform is a commodity. The ingredients may be identical. The difference is social: the second meal is produced under a division of labour organised for sale, and access to it is mediated by money.

Commodity form, not “stuff.”

A commodity is not defined by being physical. Services can be commodities. Digital products can be commodities. What matters is the social form: production for sale in a system where producers must secure their livelihoods through the market. When that condition becomes general, commodity exchange is no longer a marginal activity. It becomes a coercive organiser of life.

3.2 Use-value

Use-value refers to concrete usefulness: food nourishes, a phone enables communication, antibiotics treat an infection, electricity powers lighting and machines. Use-values are qualitative and historically varied. They exist in all societies. A society can be rich in use-values and yet poor in money; it can produce what people need and still not generate profit.

This matters because capitalism does not organise production directly around use-values. Under capitalism, use-values are typically produced only insofar as they can carry exchange-value. Housing is built not primarily to house, but to realise rent and capital gains. Healthcare is organised not primarily as care, but as an industry. Food distribution is organised not primarily according to need, but according to purchasing power. This is one way capitalism can generate simultaneous abundance and deprivation: useful things exist, but access is conditional on money.

3.3 Exchange-value

Exchange-value is the quantitative relation in which one commodity exchanges for another: one coat for twenty metres of linen, one month of labour-power for a wage, one laptop for a certain sum of money. In capitalist societies, this relation typically appears as a money price.

Markets are old; generalised commodity dependence is not.

Money and markets can exist in many kinds of society; merchants traded, coins circulated, and taxes or tribute were sometimes paid in money long before capitalism. But in many pre-capitalist settings exchange was episodic, bounded by custom, tribute, or status, and money did not function as a universal mediator of everyday life. Large parts of life were organised through direct obligation and production for use: rent in kind, customary dues, corvée labour, household and village production, and systems of redistribution. Commodity exchange often existed, but it was frequently limited or secondary to these relations.

Capitalism generalises commodity exchange so that money becomes the universal equivalent: most goods and services are routinely bought and sold, and survival itself depends on access to money. That is why under capitalism the typical question is not only what is produced, but what can be sold, to whom, and for how much— including the selling of labour-power for wages.

Price as the form of appearance.

When value is expressed in money, it appears as a price. Prices fluctuate with supply and demand, market power, speculation, and crises. Later (see Section 7.2) we return to why prices do not systematically coincide with underlying values, even though they are not arbitrary.

3.4 The question that leads to value

What interests Marx is: what regulates these exchange ratios over the long run? Why does a high-end smartphone sell for many times the price of a sack of rice, even though rice is more essential to life?

Answers based on status, taste, or desire—“luxury is valued more,” “people desire phones”—do not explain the regularities of market exchange. Nor does “scarcity” in the abstract explain why commodities produced in massive quantities can still exchange at high prices while necessities can be cheap. Marx’s claim is that the commensurability of commodities on the market points to a social common substance: the organisation of social labour rather than usefulness as such. To develop that claim, we now have to distinguish the appearance of value in exchange and price from its underlying determination: socially necessary labour time.

3.5 Labour and value

Marx’s answer is the labour theory of value. Very roughly, the value of a commodity is proportional to the socially necessary labour time required to produce it.

\[ \ensuremath{V_{i}} = \MELT\,\ensuremath{L^{\mathrm{SN}}_{i}}, \tag{3.1} \]

where:

  • \(\ensuremath{V_{i}}\) is the value (in money terms) of one unit of commodity \(i\);

  • \(\ensuremath{L^{\mathrm{SN}}_{i}}\) is the socially necessary labour time required to produce one unit of commodity \(i\): that is, the labour time needed under average conditions of production, with average skill and intensity, using the prevailing technology.

  • \(\MELT\) is the monetary expression of labour time (MELT): a proportionality constant that converts labour-time into money magnitudes, i.e. the amount of money that corresponds to one hour of socially necessary labour time in a given country and period (money per hour of \(\mathrm{SNLT}\)). In the simplified examples below, \(\MELT\) functions as an expository money-per-labour-hour conversion factor. A fuller monetary treatment defines the MELT at the aggregate level and distinguishes newly added value from the monetary valuation of transferred input values.

We formalise \(\mathrm{SNLT}\) as a social average across producers in Section 4 (Eq. (4.1)).

Complex labour (skilled labour).

In Marx’s framework, complex labour counts as multiplied simple labour; see the focused note in Section 3.1 for how this reduction is socially stabilised under capitalism.

Suppose a smartphone model takes \(4\) hours of direct and indirect labour time across the global supply chain (direct assembly labour plus the labour embodied in parts, transport, and logistics), and a basic T-shirt takes \(0.5\) hours, then the ratio of their values (and thus their exchange-values in the value-theoretic sense) will tend, other things equal, to be about

\[ \frac{\ensuremath{V_{\text{phone}}}}{\ensuremath{V_{\text{shirt}}}} = \frac{\MELT\,\ensuremath{L^{\mathrm{SN}}_{\text{phone}}}}{\MELT\,\ensuremath{L^{\mathrm{SN}}_{\text{shirt}}}} \approx \frac{4}{0.5} = 8, \]

so the phone’s exchange-value tends to be about eight times the shirt’s (an \(8{:}1\) ratio).

Market prices fluctuate around these values due to supply, demand, speculation, brand power, and state policy, but in Marx’s framework the underlying regulator of prices over the long run is labour time through competition and the formation of prices of production (see Section 7.2). Value appears in money-prices through the mediations of competition, productivity differences, and the redistribution of surplus value across capitals.

Complex labour, skill, and the reduction to simple labour

The labour-time that regulates value is social labour reduced to a common unit of simple labour. Concrete labours differ in skill, training, and intensity; Marx treats complex (skilled) labour as multiplied simple labour—that is, one hour of skilled labour counts as several hours of average labour.[5]

This “reduction” is not an individual choice made in the market each morning. It is a durable social process: institutions, training pipelines, credential regimes, and workplace hierarchies stabilise what counts as “average” labour in each branch over time. In capitalism, wage hierarchies and professional closure help register and reproduce these differences, although wages do not themselves create value.[52, 36]

3.6 Common sceptical objections: supply and demand, “time is not value”, skilled labour, and the market

A cluster of sceptical objections appears again and again in discussions of Marx: some are posed in the language of “preferences” and supply–demand, others in the language of “measurement” and epistemology (“time is not value”), and others in the language of skill (“is an hour of a surgeon the same as an hour of a miner?”). They are worth taking seriously, because they are also the points where capitalist appearances are most deceptive.

The key is to be clear about what kind of object value is. Many critics treat “value” as if it were a natural substance like length or weight, and then declare a scandal when Marx uses labour-time. But Marx’s claim is different and more specific: value is a social relation that takes a quantitative form under generalised commodity production. The relevant question is not “Can I see value directly on a price tag?” The question is: what social process makes heterogeneous private labours comparable and forces production to conform to a social average?

Objection 1: “Aren’t prices just supply, demand, and preferences?”

Of course market prices move with supply and demand. Marx’s claim is different: those movements are oscillations around regulating magnitudes anchored in production conditions and the allocation of social labour under competition.[5, 36]

Short-run price fluctuations must be distinguished from the long-run discipline imposed by production conditions and competition. A failed harvest can raise grain prices; a war can spike energy prices; a fashion wave can raise sneaker prices. But none of this explains why, across vast and heterogeneous industries, technical change that reduces labour per unit tends to reduce the value of commodities over time, nor why competition systematically reallocates capital in search of an average rate of profit.[5, 36] Supply and demand explains movement; it does not explain the centre of gravity around which those movements occur or why that centre shifts with productivity.

Marginalist theory treats “value” as subjective utility. But utilities cannot explain why private labours become comparable in definite proportions, why outputs become exchangeable on a regular basis, and why the system reproduces itself by enforcing cost and time discipline. What needs explaining is the social commensuration itself: why the labour of strangers can be treated as equivalent, and why the market punishes producers whose methods are persistently out of line with the prevailing average. That commensuration is what the category of socially necessary labour time captures.[5]

Objection 2: “You measure value by time, but time is not value.”

True: time is not value in the way centimetres are length. Marx is not committing a category error. He is explaining why, under capitalism, social labour is compelled to take a commensurable form, and why labour-time is the relevant measure of that commensuration.

Under generalised commodity production, producers are not coordinating directly as a conscious plan. They coordinate through exchange. That requires that different concrete labours (sewing, coding, teaching, mining) be reduced to a common social denominator. Marx calls that denominator abstract labour. Value is the quantitative expression of that abstract social labour, and the unit of abstract labour is socially necessary labour time: the time required under average conditions, with average skill and normal intensity, using prevailing techniques.[5, 36]

This is why “socially necessary” does the heavy lifting. The labour-time that counts is not the individual’s idiosyncratic time, and not mere clock-time taken in isolation. It is time normalised by social averages of technique, intensity, and skill, and enforced by the competitive discipline that compels producers to match prevailing conditions (see Section 4.1). 1

Objection 3: “Is an hour of a surgeon equal to an hour of a miner?”

As clock-time, yes: an hour is an hour. As abstract labour, not necessarily. Marx distinguishes simple (average) labour from complex (skilled) labour. Complex labour counts as multiplied simple labour: one hour of skilled labour can count as several hours of average labour.[5]

This is not a judgement on the worth of different people. How this division comes into being and is socially produced (training pipelines, credential regimes, closure, wage hierarchies, and uneven social reproduction costs) is discussed in Section 3.1.[52, 36]

Objection 4: “If the market determines what counts as socially necessary, then there is no law.”

Here the critic mixes up validation with determination.

Yes: under capitalism, private labour is only validated as social labour through sale. Commodities that cannot be sold under normal conditions are devalorised, and the loss appears as write-downs, layoffs, bankruptcies, and idle capacity.[5, 36] But this does not mean that “prices determine value” in an arbitrary or purely subjective way. It means that a society organised through private production and exchange has no direct social accounting of labour; the market becomes the coercive mechanism through which social averages are imposed.

The “law” should not be read as an ethical rule or a perfect measuring instrument. It is a tendential regulator: competition reallocates production toward techniques closer to the social average and penalises producers whose unit labour-time is persistently above it (Section 4.1). Over time, this pressure forms centres of gravitation. Market prices oscillate around regulating magnitudes anchored in production conditions, even though the surface is noisy, crisis-prone, and shaped by power.[36]

Illustrative approximation: weighted social averages.

When different firms or regions produce the same commodity with different unit labour-times, the conditions supplying a large share of socially validated output tend to exert a strong influence on the regulating social norm. For a simplified illustration, we can approximate this through an output-weighted average. This should not be read as a general definition of socially necessary labour time, but as a pedagogical way of showing why the dominant conditions of production within a branch matter.2

Objection 5: “So is value measurable or not?”

Value is not usually directly observable as a price tag in the way mass is observable on a scale. But that does not make it metaphysical. It makes it a social relation whose effects are observable through its regularities: productivity change tends to reduce values; capitals with persistently higher unit labour-time are disciplined; and competition generates a tendency toward average profit that redistributes surplus value (Section 7.2).[5, 36]

This is also why we keep three distinct levels explicit later: values, prices of production, and market prices (Section 7.2). Confusing these levels is the fastest route to false “refutations” that treat short-run price movements as if they abolished the underlying competitive regulator.

Other recurring confusions you will see (and where we handle them).

  • “Profit is just mark-up.” We separate surplus value (production) from profit (realisation and distribution) in Section 5 and then show redistribution through prices of production in Section 7.2.

  • “Nature creates value.” We distinguish use-value (material wealth) from value (a capitalist social form) in Section 3.7.

  • “Monopoly brands / rents disprove value theory.” We show how monopoly power and rent are claims on surplus value, not new sources of it (see Sections 7.2 and 11.1).

3.7 Nature, wealth, and the source of value

A common confusion (especially in climate politics) is to say: “If nature is essential, then nature must be the source of value.” Marx’s position is more precise.

  • Nature is indispensable to production: it provides materials, energy flows, ecosystems, and conditions of life. Without nature there is no labour process and no material wealth.

  • Nature is a source of use-values (material wealth): some use-values exist with little or no human labour (sunlight, air, wild fish), while most are produced by labour working on nature.

  • Value (in the Marxian sense) is a social form specific to generalised commodity production: it is labour-time that society is compelled to treat as commensurable through exchange, regulated by socially necessary labour time and expressed in money.

So Marx does not deny nature. He is distinguishing categories. Nature helps determine how much labour is required (by shaping productivity conditions and material inputs), but under capitalism it is labour-time that appears as value in the dominant social accounting of wealth.

This distinction matters because capitalism can increase physical throughput and ecological harm while reducing the value embodied per unit (if productivity rises and \(\mathrm{SNLT}\) falls). Greater material output, energy use, and extraction can therefore coincide with falling labour-time per unit. Ecological crisis and profitability pressures can intensify together.

When natural conditions become monopolised (land, location, minerals), payments for access appear as rent. Rent is not value created by nature; it is a claim on surplus value created elsewhere, enforced by property rights over natural conditions.[6]

3.8 A modern example: the smartphone

Consider a smartphone assembled in southern China for a large brand. The example is loosely based on the cost and value-chain structures documented in electronics supply-chain studies, but the magnitudes used below are illustrative rather than a firm-year decomposition of a specific handset.[58, 41]

  • The phone retails in London for, say, £800.

  • The total wage bill for assembly workers per phone might be on the order of £10–£15.

  • The rest of the price covers constant capital (components, machinery depreciation, logistics), marketing, design, and various profits and rents.

The exchange-value of the phone vastly exceeds the direct wages paid in the factory. Part of the explanation is that value from many segments of the global supply chain is realised in the final sale; part is that monopolistic firms capture surplus value generated across the chain. To understand how, we need to go deeper into labour, surplus, and capital.


  1. If intensity rises (speed-up, piece-rates, tighter monitoring), an hour becomes “denser” in value-creation terms. This is why Marx’s unit is not a physiological constant but a social normalisation: “normal intensity” is historically specific and class-contested. ↩

  2. Marx develops a related problem in Volume III when discussing how a “market value” can be formed when individual values differ within a branch: the regulating magnitude is shaped by the conditions of production that prevail for a significant mass of output, though not always through a simple arithmetic average.[6] ↩